I don’t like the idea of miracles.
Backtrack for a second. Some people don’t believe in the Christian idea of signs and wonders. Spiritual gifts. Healings. Either that or they don’t like them. Most of my friends know I believe in and am supportive of all of the above.
But I also, still don’t like them. How’s that possible?
I think the problem is that I believe in storytelling, and I adhere to one very important rule of storytelling: everything has a cause and an effect. Characters have goals. They take action to achieve that goal. Something pushes back. They take a greater action. And this cycle continues until they succeed or fail.
Which is why I find the catch-all solution of Deus Ex Machina to be so off-putting. At the end, when all seems lost, and the protagonist is unable to go against all odds to achieve his goal, someone else swoops in and magically rescues the situation from the proverbial jaws of defeat.
I hate this because it renders everything a character did obsolete. It makes everything he did pointless. It means that there, in actuality, was no effort required to achieve that goal, which then begs the question of whether or not that goal was worth anything to begin with.
It also means it is impossible to duplicate. Because who knows when the powers that be will decide at the last second to rewrite the foundation of the future.
To me, miracles, are Deus Ex Machina. It’s magic. Completely unexplainable. I realize now I’m potentially shooting my foot when it comes to my friends understanding my personality–but here goes.
When someone tells me God rearranged their messed up jaw through someone’s prayer (true story by the way), one part of me is happy for them–happy that they don’t have to pay thousands of dollars to go to a dentist. Happy that they can eat normally.
But honestly, the other half of me feels like I paid $10 to watch a bad movie where the bad guy is about to kill the good guy except a car hits him at the end and the good guy survives. It’s not satisfying.
Or what if in Star Wars, instead of the tense movie that resulted in the epic battle at the Death Star, we saw Darth Vader run around killing people for 90 minutes, and then at the end he meets a guy named Obi-Wan Kenobi who shines a flashlight in Vader’s face, after which Vader decides ok I will now be a good guy? Nobody would watch it. No one.
Yet this is exactly the Biblical story of Paul’s conversion. Light shines down while he’s walking and suddenly he’s a good guy. Why does that only happen to Paul? Why can’t that happen to everyone? And it doesn’t even feel believable. If he so readily switches sides, there must have been more going on. Either he had doubts about what he was doing. Or he had mental pain from the last guy he had killed, something. Unless the light was just so overbearing he had no other choice.
Which, again, raises the question: Why doesn’t this happen to everyone?
This just might be the very first question I ask God when I get the chance. Why does it feel like at times, someone just snaps their fingers and all is well?
No good books, movies, or even songs use this mechanic. Imagine a disaster movie where for 100 minutes the world panics about an imminent collision with an asteroid. Except at the very last second, an astral wind blows the asteroid away and everything goes back to the way it was.
All good stories are about someone who takes action and fights for something he wants. It doesn’t mean that he is alone; In fact, the journey always involves the help and action of others around. But it does not change the fact that they achieved their goal without the help of a random outside source that appears from left field.
Not even the salvation story uses this tactic. There was no mysterious power that jumped in and said, “Oh, I think I’ll just come now and fix everything.”
Salvation took work. Jesus had to die. And he was not some mysterious being that appeared out of where.
You ever see a movie where the protagonist, has a sidekick, and they fight for something that requires the protagonist to give his life to achieve his goal? And through his death the sidekick and everyone else will be able to enjoy that goal for the rest of their own lives?
That’s a good story. That’s the salvation story. Not some Deus Ex Machina, astral wind moving the asteroid, miracle.